Sexual Abuse Case Against Priest Dropped But Retired Priest Validates the Victim’s Claims

“A retired Winona priest is coming forward after allegations of child abuse were tossed out by the Minnesota Supreme Court on Wednesday.

Retired Fr. James Edward Fitzpatrick of Diocese of Winona says he knew for decades his church had covered up allegations of abuse by victims.

“It’s a matter of conscience,” Fitzpatrick said. “It’s been bothering me for years.”

If it was a matter of conscience, he would have had one decades ago.

“Fitzpatrick and others are accusing retired priest Thomas Adamson of abusing more than a dozen children and the Archdiocese of St. Paul -Minneapolis of knowingly covering it up.

“I first knew about it first hand in 1965 when two sets of parents came to me at the Cathedral of the Sacred Heart in Winona and told me about their sons being abused by Tom Adamson,” Fitzpatrick said.

Fitzpatrick kept silent out of fear of losing his job.”

I guess he doesn’t have fear of losing his job anymore.

“Adamson was later assigned to Church of the Risen Savior in Burnsville, Minn., in 1981. Jim Keenan, 45, attended the church during that time and was an altar boy.

On Wednesday, Keenan had his abuse case tossed out of the Minnesota Supreme Court. His lawsuit was based on a repressed memory. Keenan says he was abused by Adamson several times between 1980 and 1981. In 2006 he sued the Archdiocese of St. Paul-Minneapolis well outside the six year statute of limitations.

“The science of repressed memory wasn’t considered science enough to be admissible in court,” Keenan said. “I’m disappointed but I’m certainly not going to be quiet.”

Good for you!

If the case would’ve gone to trial, Fitzpatrick would’ve testified how the church moved Adamson around after abuse allegations surfaced. Keenan’s attorney, Jeff Anderson, also had letters written by church leaders discussing the abuse by Adamson.

One letter reads: “In the counseling process at St. Cloud, it became evident that (blank name) was also sexually abused from 1978 to 1982. I asked Father Adamson about this and he admitted and, in fact, he had abused the boy during that period of time. I did not go into sexual activity, but Father Adamson agreed that it probably would be first degree sexual contact.”

Anderson has a list of 46 priests from the Archdiocese of Winona and St. Paul-Minneapolis accused of abuse. The list was given to Anderson by church bishops, but it was sealed by a protective order. Anderson says if the case would’ve gone to trial, he would’ve made the list public.

“Two times in this case we’ve been back to court trying to get that list released,” Anderson said. “This is a public safety issue.”

Keenan says his lawsuit was never about money. What he wanted was a policy change within the church.

“I want them to live like the rest of us,” Keenan said. “I have a staff of 47; we work with children with special needs. If a staffer of mine touches a child, they don’t get to go in front of another child. My first call is to 911.”

Right on!

In a statement Thursday, the Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis said it “deeply regrets any pain or harm caused by Adamson.”

It said Adamson was removed from public ministry in 1984 and that the abuse claims made about him have been public for more than 20 years.

“We are very sorry for any mistakes made in the handling of this situation,” the archdiocese said.”

A mistake is putting your car keys in the wrong place.

What they did was criminal and a grave choice.



This entry was posted in Priest Abuse, rape and abuse, Religion, repressed memory and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Sexual Abuse Case Against Priest Dropped But Retired Priest Validates the Victim’s Claims

  1. little nel says:

    There is a famous painting that depicts a child rape victim killing her rapist with a knife.

    Her violent rapist had never been held accountable for what he had done to her because he was legally untouchable. He was also a friend of her father who was a famous painter.

    When she became an adult, she painted herself killing him because that is how she felt about him after he smugly got away with it and considered the rape like a sporting event.

    I remember seeing that painting and feeling her rage at the unjust treatment she endured and her pent up pain that she wanted to be rid of. I remember thinking that the bastard was getting what he really deserved for what he did to her.

    That is how I felt about the night matron and it scared me that I could feel such rage towards someone. I used to fantasize that I grew up and killed her because I wanted some justice for what had happened to me.

  2. Beverley says:

    I remember reading years ago that the Catholic church could not get insurance to cover for the possibility of being accused of child abuse.
    I wonder if this is still true?

Comments are closed.